Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe and can be used in various applications, from powering vehicles to storing energy generated by renewable sources. When used in fuel cells, hydrogen combines with oxygen to produce electricity, with water vapor as the only byproduct1. This seemingly clean process has positioned hydrogen as a key player in the transition to sustainable energy systems.
Hydrogen can be produced through different methods, classified based on their environmental impact:
While green hydrogen is the most environmentally friendly, its production is resource-intensive, particularly in terms of water usage.
Green hydrogen production requires substantial amounts of fresh water, a resource that is increasingly scarce in many parts of the world4. Electrolysis, the process used to produce green hydrogen, demands large volumes of water and significant energy inputs. This makes green hydrogen both expensive and environmentally taxing, especially in regions already facing water shortages4.
Hydrogen is highly flammable and requires careful handling and storage. Its low ignition energy and wide flammability range make it more prone to leaks and explosions compared to other fuels5. The storage infrastructure for hydrogen must be robust and leak-proof, adding to the overall costs and complexity of hydrogen energy systems.
Transitioning to a hydrogen-based energy system necessitates significant investments in new infrastructure, including production facilities, storage systems, and distribution networks6. Building this infrastructure is not only expensive but also time-consuming, potentially delaying the adoption of more proven renewable technologies like wind and solar power7.
Wind and solar power have emerged as reliable and cost-effective renewable energy sources. Unlike hydrogen, these technologies do not require extensive water resources and have already demonstrated scalability and efficiency. Investments in wind and solar have led to substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, making them more immediate solutions to climate change8.
Storing energy is a crucial component of transitioning to true renewable energy. Effective energy storage solutions ensure that energy generated from intermittent sources like wind and solar can be reliably used when needed. There are several alternative energy storage options beyond hydrogen:
Lithium-ion batteries offer an effective means of energy storage, complementing renewable energy sources by storing excess power for later use9. Batteries are generally more efficient and easier to integrate into existing energy systems compared to hydrogen storage. Additionally, the battery industry is rapidly advancing, with decreasing costs and improving technologies enhancing their viability as a primary energy storage solution10.
Batteries have their own challenges, particularly their dependence on rare and expensive materials and the current lack of recycling infrastructure to reuse the raw materials. According to data released in a new report by the International Energy Agency11, the recycling rates of many metals critical for green energy transitions are low and have only risen slowly over the last years.
The potential to recycle materials from old batteries and electronics is massive and has the potential to make batteries an even better option for sustainable energy storage11.
Bidirectional EVs, also known as vehicle-to-grid (V2G) systems, can act as mobile energy storage units. These vehicles can not only draw power from the grid to charge their batteries but also feed excess energy back into the grid when needed12. This technology enhances the flexibility and resilience of the energy system by utilizing the distributed storage capacity of EVs. However, widespread adoption requires significant advancements in infrastructure and regulatory frameworks to manage the bidirectional flow of electricity effectively12.
Focusing on electrification and improving energy efficiency presents a more straightforward and less risky path to decarbonization than relying on hydrogen16. Electrification leverages existing infrastructure and technologies, allowing for quicker implementation and scaling without the same level of resource demands as hydrogen. Additionally, integrating Distributed Energy Resources (DER) and Virtual Power Plants (VPP) can enhance the flexibility and resilience of the energy system17.
Distributed Energy Resources (DER) include small-scale power generation technologies such as solar panels, wind turbines, and battery storage systems that are located close to where energy is consumed17. Virtual Power Plants (VPP) aggregate multiple DERs to operate as a single power plant, providing services like demand response and grid stabilization17. These technologies enable more efficient and resilient energy systems by reducing transmission losses and enhancing local energy management.
Furthermore, transitioning to renewables and electrification can address significant inefficiencies in our current energy systems. According to a study highlighted in the YouTube video “The Mind-Blowing Thing We Get WRONG About Energy” by DW Planet A18, over two-thirds of all energy generated is lost as “rejected energy” due to inefficiencies at every stage, from generation in fossil-fuel power plants to everyday appliances. Renewable energy sources like wind and solar bypass many of these inefficiencies by eliminating the need to burn fuel, and electric technologies such as electric vehicles and heat pumps use energy more directly and efficiently18. In contrast, hydrogen does not significantly reduce waste from our existing infrastructure, as it continues to rely on an inefficient system that burns fuels, maintaining the status quo rather than promoting greater efficiency18.
Most hydrogen produced today is grey or blue, meaning it relies on fossil fuels and can still result in significant CO₂ emissions19. While blue hydrogen aims to mitigate this through carbon capture, the effectiveness and scalability of CCS technologies remain uncertain19. This raises questions about the true environmental benefits of hydrogen when it is not produced sustainably.
Green hydrogen’s reliance on fresh water poses a significant environmental challenge. In regions where water is already limited, diverting large quantities to hydrogen production could exacerbate water scarcity issues, impacting agriculture, drinking water supplies, and ecosystems20.
There is growing concern that oil companies are leveraging hydrogen as a means to maintain their market dominance and delay more substantial shifts to renewable energy21. By investing in hydrogen technologies, these companies can position themselves as environmentally responsible while continuing to extract and sell fossil fuels. This strategy may divert attention and resources away from proven renewable technologies, hindering the overall transition to a sustainable energy future21.
Adopting hydrogen as a primary energy solution requires a genuine commitment to reducing carbon emissions. However, the current focus on hydrogen, especially grey and blue variants, may serve more as a marketing tool for oil companies rather than a meaningful step toward sustainability22. To ensure that hydrogen contributes positively to climate goals, it is essential to prioritize green hydrogen production and invest in technologies that genuinely lower carbon emissions22.
While hydrogen presents some promising applications in the energy sector, it is accompanied by significant dangers and drawbacks that cannot be overlooked. The high resource demands, safety concerns, and substantial infrastructure investments required for hydrogen production and storage make it a less attractive option compared to established renewable technologies like wind and solar power. Furthermore, the potential for oil companies to use hydrogen as a strategy to maintain their dominance raises concerns about the true environmental benefits of hydrogen adoption.
We should not invest in rebuilding our infrastructure until we are fully capable of replacing the existing black/grey/blue hydrogen with green hydrogen. Only then can we trust to move forward with hydrogen as a viable option.
11/21/2024 – This article has been written by the FalseSolutions.Org team
References
